Calling out hatred…

An open letter to the Philippine Airlines (PAL) on the gender insensitivity of the Philippine carrier’s monthly publication, Mabuhay.

SIMEON S. VENTURA JR.
Editor in Chief
Mabuhay (Philippine Airlines’ Inflight Travel+Lifestyle Magazine)

Sir:

This is to bring to your attention a gender-insensitive mistake in the issue for the month of June of Mabuhay, Philippine Airlines’ (PAL) monthly inflight magazine. Dubbed as your Pride Issue, it – rightfully so, if I may say so myself – features people (most of them Filipinos) who supposedly help make the wheels of change turn for the good of the Philippines. You deserve kudos for highlighting the goodness of the Filipino people as we mark this year’s Philippine Independence Day (in June, our “Pride month”).

Celebrating Pride during the month of June is, incidentally, also done by the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community in many parts of the world, including many LGBTs in the Philippines. This actually honors the valiant efforts of members of the LGBT community during the Stonewall riots, a series of spontaneous (and, unfortunately, violent) demonstrations against a police raid that took place in the early morning hours of June 28, 1969, at the Stonewall Inn in the Greenwich Village in New York City in the US. There was a time when – prior to the Stonewall riots – LGBTs chose to turn the other cheek, opting to ignore the government-backed system that persecuted them (and other sexual minorities), but that changed that night in June, now celebrated to mark the start of the modern times’ gay rights movement in the US and, yes, around the world.

Fortunately, the LGBT community has made progress (albeit slowly) in promoting equal treatment for all, irrespective of sexual orientation and gender identity and expression. We know, however, that much remains to be done, with erroneous beliefs about us still being perpetrated even by those in positions that can influence policies that should support acceptance, not discrimination.

Referring to TG women as “Mister”, as the title does, is erroneous and, yes, insensitive. Doing so in a derisive manner, as the title ends up insinuating, is even more aggravating.

It is with sadness, therefore, that I’d like to point out to you what I found disturbing in Mabuhay’s June issue.

On Page 31, in the section entitled “IN THE NEWS”, a short paragraph deals with the decision of Miss Universe to allow transgenders (TGs) to compete in the annual beauty pageant. To wit:

MISS…TER UNIVERSE?
Though its doors are still closed to mothers and married women, the Miss Universe beauty pageant will now allow transgender women to compete starting 2013, after letting 23-year-old Jenna Talackova compete in the Miss Universe Canada last May 2012.

Referring to TG women as “Mister”, as the title does, is erroneous and, yes, insensitive. Doing so in a derisive manner, as the title ends up insinuating, is even more aggravating.

This does not completely reflect the TG experience, but transgenderism has been somewhat simply defined as the “non-identification with, or non-presentation as, the gender one was assigned at birth”. With this, Ms Talackova may have been born male, but she IS a woman (she started hormone therapy at 14, and she even had sex reassignment when she was 19). Imposing heteronormative concepts on her personal sense of identity is specious.

When the June issue of Mabuhay was first seen by us, I was told that complaining is akin to making a mountain out of an anthill – after all, the entire TG article is but a few lines.

However, while it may just be a few lines, alas, we cannot, and should not just dismiss it as such.

Even among members of the LGBT community, the TGs are considered to be even more discriminated against. For instance, in a report (Injustice at Every Turn: A Report of the National Transgender Discrimination Survey) released in February 2011, the National Center for Transgender Equality (NCTE) and the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force (NGLTF) found that 90% of TG people faced discrimination at work, and were unemployed at double the rate of the general population; over half had been harassed or turned away when attempting to access public services; and 41% of those surveyed reported attempting suicide, over 26 times the rate of 1.6% in the general population.

The problems reflected by these figures are interconnected. As the study also highlighted, “these numbers were greatly related to other factors tested, increasing for people who had lost a job due to discrimination (an especially relevant factor because transgender people faced double the general rate of unemployment, and 90% faced discrimination at work), were harassed at school (which occurred to almost eight out of every 10 people who were transgender or expressed gender non-conformity in grades K-12), had little household income, or were a victim of assault.”

It may sound simplistic, but how we address TGs can start the big changes in the way we treat them. On this, we cannot highlight enough the power of words in aiding LGBTs find general acceptance.

PAL is, of course, in a position to help achieve this. According to the Civil Aeronautics Board (CAB), for the months of January to March this year alone, PAL had 1,097,272 international passengers. Even the numbers of your local passengers reportedly grew by 9% for the same quarter (compared to the same period a year ago). The big number of people who see Mabuhay cannot be underestimated – we just hope that the information they get is not, in any way, anti-LGBT.

Prior to the riots in Stonewall Inn, it can be argued that the inaction of the LGBTs to face those who persecuted them made the persecution happen in the first place. We are learning the hard way even now the relevance of being proactive in our push for equal rights for all. So please bear with me as I pinpoint the erroneous addressing of TGs.

We hope that better care is taken in future stories, as we all look forward to that day when LGBTs are finally treated as equals of everyone.

MICHAEL DAVID dela Cruz TAN
Editor
Outrage Magazine

2 Responses to Calling out hatred…

  1. Pingback: Transgender rights ARE human rights | Outrage Magazine

  2. Pingback: Mabuhay apology | Outrage Magazine

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

HELP US BY HELPING YOU HIT THE RIGHT SPOT

April 2007 marked the launching of Outrage Magazine, the only Webzine made for, and by members of the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community in the Philippines.

The LGBTzine remains loyal to the reasons of its existence (i.e. to be a relevant source of info on everything LGBT-related in the Philippines), and we are proud to say that year-on-year since we were established, Outrage Magazine’s scope has broadened, too (aside from the coverage we provide, we actually have programs effecting changes to better the plight of LGBT Filipinos).

No surprise that our reach continues to grow, too, with our Website alone now getting well over 580,000 per month on average (with 10,000 of them unique hits), while our Facebook page (not counting our other online presence) getting over hundreds of thousands of unique visits per week.

Yes, there is a need for information; and yes, we’re more than willing to provide.

And just in time, too, as pink lifestyle long invading mainstream living – think Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, or IKEA, or gay speak, or disco, or brunch, or... you get the point.

This makes the LGBT market, and those it affects, a goldmine for advertisers.

Consider these:
• 81% of LGBTs are more likely to use the Internet to obtain information about goods and services (Witeck-Combs)
• 72% to 94% of LGBTs prefer to buy brands that market directly to them (Harris/Witeck-Combs &Greenfield Online)
• 89% of LGBTs are brand-affiliated, this means that it is “most likely or highly likely to actively seek out brands that had advertised in gay media” (Simmons)
• LGBTs spend an average of 30 minutes per day, 12 times per month online (Nielsen NetRatings)
• LGBTs are twice as likely to be in management positions, twice as likely to have purchased online using a credit card, 79% are willing to pay a premium of quality products and services, 94% of gays and lesbians go out of their way to purchase products and services marketed directly to them in gay media, and 79% of LGBTs are highly likely to indulge themselves (@Plan, Simmons, Greenfield Online & Witeck-Combs)

It is time to target this market, we say.

So use us.

Abuse us, even.

This is the only time we will gladly let you.

advertise@outragemag.com