Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

From the Editor

Stop this ‘B.S. advocacy’

For Michael David dela Cruz Tan, many LGBT leaders/“leaders” who represent the entire LGBT community actually refuse to listen to the very people they claim to represent. Sadly, current power structures keep them there. So for him, “only if we dismantle these structures will we be able to hear about the REAL issues, not those mouthed by people who are just there to perpetuate the status quo to sustain positions of power.”

PHOTO BY TANVIMALIK FROM PIXABAY.COM

Last year, a politician openly told me a hard truth about the Filipino LGBT community, i.e. that it is EXTREMELY divided. But then he added that we should learn to unite by backing a “leader” who happens to be a friend of his.

PHOTO BY TANVIMALIK FROM PIXABAY.COM

I couldn’t help myself from reprimanding him, telling him that he is part of the problem of the disunity of the LGBT community – i.e. when dealing with the LGBT community, he only coordinates with this person he recognizes as our “leader” even if the LGBT community as a whole does not accept this same person as such.

This politician isn’t the first to do this, of course. You only have to look at so many of the “leaders” being interviewed on behalf of the ENTIRE LGBT community to see where I’m coming from…

Yes, I get it.

  1. This continues to be a lookist society, so we end up getting someone “pretty” speak for us. If the one speaking isn’t necessarily pretty, No. 2 (below) applies.
  2. This continues to be an elitist society, and often, only those who have access to power (including mainstream media) get the chance to speak/be heard.
  3. Those in positions of power tend to move ONLY within their circles, so only those belonging to No. 1 and/or No. 2 are heard.

But these are the very reasons why, particularly in the LGBT community, “B.S. advocacy” persists (and even triumphs).

There are extremely well-compensated people who are supposed to help deal with the worsening HIV situation in the Philippines. I once asked one of them (whose Facebook wall is inundated by non-stop touring around the world disguised as “reaching out”, as well as incessant shopping) if there’s a plan to visit – even once – a treatment hub in the Philippines where the very people they claim to serve are continuing to die due to (among others) lack of funds. I was told: “No.” This person now just ignores me… while the world tour and incessant shopping continue…

I know of a Metro Manila-based NGO that is pushing for an anti-discrimination ordinance in a city outside of Metro Manila because an international funder is (sort of) demanding it. So they’re pushing for this… sans the involvement of the local LGBT community.

There are people with the global platform to speak about HIV, and yet publicly shame people living with HIV.

I know of people representing the entire LGBT community while pushing for the anti-discrimination bill (ADB), but won’t engage those who will question their version of the bill.

But sadly, so many of these people are the ones we see; the ones we hear from; the ones who claim to represent us.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

And just as sadly, the current power structures keep them there.

And it is these structures that we need to dismantle if we want the LGBT community to be strengthened, even if not “united”. Only if we dismantle these structures will we be able to hear about the REAL issues, not those mouthed by people who are just there to perpetuate the status quo to sustain positions of power.

Yes, we have space/s for everyone. In fact, the spotlight for representation is – in theory – big enough to accommodate those who are willing to die for the cause, and those who just want to profit from it.

But we need to start distinguishing advocates from “advocates”; we need to see beyond this cult of personalities, where select people who do not necessarily do anything to advance our causes benefit from our sufferings.

This is our duty as members of the (still divided) LGBT community.

We also need to start calling out not only the latter, but those that promote them.

Because if we don’t, then the “B.S. advocacy” will just thrive.

And what about that politician?

He went quiet when I presented to him my position about his friend, who he says we all should just back blindly. I am not sure he’d listen (I was told he’s somewhat hardheaded). But I sure won’t stop raising this up – including to him if he, again, ONLY speaks to his friend as a representative of the entire LGBT community…

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The founder of Outrage Magazine, Michael David dela Cruz Tan completed BA Communication Studies from University of Newcastle in NSW, Australia; and Master of Development Communication from the University of the Philippines-Open University. He grew up in Mindanao (particularly Kidapawan and Cotabato City), but he "really came out in Sydney" so that "I sort of know what it's like to be gay in a developing, and a developed world". Conversant in Filipino Sign Language, Mick can: photograph, do artworks with mixed media, write (DUH!), shoot flicks, community organize, facilitate, lecture, and research (with pioneering studies under his belt). He authored "Being LGBT in Asia: Philippines Country Report", and "Red Lives" that creatively retells stories from the local HIV community. Among others, Mick received the Catholic Mass Media Awards in 2006 for Best Investigative Journalism, and Art that Matters - Literature from Amnesty Int'l Philippines in 2020. Cross his path is the dare (guarantee: It won't be boring).

Advertisement
Advertisement

Like Us On Facebook

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

NEWSMAKERS

Men with X and Y variations can successfully serve in the workplace but experience many medical and psychiatric comorbidities that could potentially be prevented...

#KaraniwangLGBT

Growing up, Ricalyn was was called 'balaki' (half male, half female). Eventually discovering she's intersex, she became an activist, wanting to teach intersex people...

Health & Wellness

LGBT adults are twice as likely to report negative experiences while receiving health care in the last three years. This included being treated unfairly...

NEWSMAKERS

While overall IPV severity increased with age, adolescents exhibited a significantly higher incidence of sexual assault than emerging adults and adults.

Advertisement