Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

From the Editor

Is Sara Duterte-Carpio part of the LGBTQIA community?

So Davao City mayor Sara Duterte-Carpio, who is gunning to be vice president of the Philippines in the May 2022 elections, is ruffling feathers because of her claim that she’s part of the LGBTQIA community. Is she speaking a “truth”?

Short answer: If she says she is, she is.

So Davao City mayor Sara Duterte-Carpio, who is gunning to be vice president of the Philippines in the May 2022 elections, is ruffling feathers particularly among those aligned with current VP Leni Robredo, who – herself – is targeting the presidency because of her claim that she’s part of the LGBTQIA community.

Speaking to members an LGBTQIA organization aligned with her father, Pres. Rodrigo Roa Duterte, Sara is said to have said she loves LGBTQIA people because she is one.

There are… additional statements that could cause confusion – i.e. Sara then associated the aforementioned claim with her preference to do work stereotypically done by men, and to present herself in a manner also stereotypically associated with men (e.g. shaving her head).

In a way, therefore, Ms Naomi Fontanos of trans organization GANDA Filipinas Inc. was right when she said that “no, Inday, sporting short hair doesn’t make one a man. Saying so affirms traditional gender roles that are oppressive to the #LGBTIQ community w/c you’re falsely claiming to be part of.”

But – here’s the catch – claiming outright that Sara’s identity is not what she says it is, is wrong.

This needs to be stressed since many have been claiming Sara’s identity is this or that, as if speaking for Sara herself. I’ve seen online posts that went as far as saying that – if Sara is LGBTQIA – then they’d rather not be LGBTQIA anymore (in itself problematic as it promotes the notion that being LGBTQIA means one has to “conform” to someone’s idea of what “LGBTQIA” is supposed to be; and if one doesn’t fit it, then these self-declared gatekeepers won’t give others the space within the LGBTQIA community).

Whenever we discuss sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, and sex characteristics (SOGIESC) 101, we always emphasize the importance of “self identification”.

So – yeah – Sara may be confusing gender identity with gender expression. Or maybe she’s not. I don’t know her enough to know her way of thinking. For that matter, I am not her; and I can’t speak for her. So – to stress – what she says she is, she is.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

For me, the conversations – particularly since we are perhaps being queer-baited, or not – should also be focused elsewhere, i.e. on what those gunning for public posts have done and plan to do to make society more inclusive of LGBTQIA people.

Fontanos rightfully lamented that Sara – as mayor – has yet to sign the Implementing Rules and Regulations of Davao City’s anti-discrimination ordinance; though Sara’s local administration claimed it established the Rainbow Magnegsyo Ta Day, a livelihood training and business capital assistance program for members of the LGBTQIA community.

Extending this discussion to the other side of the political spectrum, VP Leni has long been cited for being pro-LGBTQIA; but at the same time, notice how no one (even among her staunchest supporters) is extensively discussing her “separate but equal” position re marriage equality; the inclusion in her senatorial slate of re-electionist Sen. Joel Villanueva, who has been repeatedly called out for opposing the prompt passage of the SOGIE Equality Bill in the Senate; and her decision to choose Sen. Manny “masahol pa sa hayop” Pacquiao as her preferred president if she’s not running for the same office.

Again, refocus the conversations.

These – i.e. what they did, are doing and what they plan to do – should be what we focus on.

Not (just) Sara’s self-identity.

Because – again – in the end, that’s hers to make.

The founder of Outrage Magazine, Michael David dela Cruz Tan completed BA Communication Studies from University of Newcastle in NSW, Australia; and Master of Development Communication from the University of the Philippines-Open University. He grew up in Mindanao (particularly Kidapawan and Cotabato City), but he "really came out in Sydney" so that "I sort of know what it's like to be gay in a developing, and a developed world". Conversant in Filipino Sign Language, Mick can: photograph, do artworks with mixed media, write (DUH!), shoot flicks, community organize, facilitate, lecture, and research (with pioneering studies under his belt). He authored "Being LGBT in Asia: Philippines Country Report", and "Red Lives" that creatively retells stories from the local HIV community. Among others, Mick received the Catholic Mass Media Awards in 2006 for Best Investigative Journalism, and Art that Matters - Literature from Amnesty Int'l Philippines in 2020. Cross his path is the dare (guarantee: It won't be boring).

Advertisement
Advertisement

Like Us On Facebook

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

NEWSMAKERS

28% of Gen Z adults — or those who are aged 18 to 25 — identify as LGBTQ, much higher than the percentage of...

NEWSMAKERS

Changes in male gender expression from adolescence to young adulthood align closely with the gender norms present in individuals’ school environments, and that these...

NEWSMAKERS

Gender-diverse and lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth are far more open to having these personal conversations with health care providers than their straight and...

From the Editor

Davao City has an anti-discrimination ordinance, and yet LGBTQIA discrimination still happens. This may be said to exemplify a failed attempt at real LGBTQIA...

Advertisement